Skip to main content

Comment Closure (Backcheck)

After a review round, someone has to confirm that all the comments were actually addressed. Comment Closure does that pass for you: give it the review comments, and it checks each one against the submittal, confirming what's resolved and what still isn't. This is the step most reviewers call the backcheck; some firms' QC procedures call it verify or recheck.

Use case: verify that all 40 reviewer comments from the last round were actually addressed.

Updated video coming soonComment Closure (Backcheck)
Available on request

Comment Closure is on for new organizations. If your workspace predates it and you don't see it in the Tools panel, talk to us.

How it works​

  1. In a project, open Comment Closure from the Tools panel (under Audit).
  2. Under Comments, pick the review comments: an Excel comment sheet or a marked-up PDF that's already in the project. If your reviewers work in Bluebeam, pull their markups in directly first. A PDF has to carry real markup annotations (comments, clouds, callouts made in Bluebeam or Acrobat). A typed comment-response letter, or a flattened PDF where the markups are printed into the page, has none and the closure can't read it: use the Excel comment sheet instead.
  3. Under PDF, pick the submittal to close the comments out against.
  4. Press Start Closure. The platform reads each comment, finds the relevant location in the submittal, and judges whether the requested change was made.

Past runs are listed under Recent closures, so you can reopen one or delete it.

Comment Closure setup with its Comments and PDF pickers

Triaging results​

Each comment comes back with one of three statuses, with evidence from the drawing so you can confirm the call:

  • Resolved - just needs a quick confirm.
  • Not resolved - your real punch list.
  • Investigate - the platform couldn't be sure, so it says so rather than guessing. It never quietly closes a comment that wasn't fixed.

Filter by status with the pills at the top, search by text or comment number (for example "12" or "10-20"), and sort by comment number or status.

Disagree with a call? Change any comment's status yourself from its status menu. Your initials show next to it, so the team can see who set it.

A few comments are counted but not checked, and the header says so:

  • Markups rejected by the design team, or cancelled by their author, in Bluebeam.
  • Items that are reference-only, marked Not verified.
A finished Comment Closure run: 21 comments with All, Resolved, Investigate and Not resolved counts, one comment open with its evidence, and the comment boxed on both the marked-up PDF and the resubmittal

Taking it further​

  • Download the comment spreadsheet with Status, Evidence and Action filled in, ready to send back.
  • Use Ask in chat on a comment to work out what to do about it with the project chat.

Why it matters​

Comment closure is where things slip: a comment acknowledged in the response letter but never picked up in the drawings. Checking each comment against the sheets, not against the response narrative, catches exactly that.